Evaluate Code Review

Feedback is already in hand from a human reviewer, one or more AI bots (Copilot, CodeRabbit, Devin, Bito, Greptile), a prior self-review, or a markdown audit doc. The job is triage, not authoring. Discipline: verify before implementing, technical correctness over social comfort, no performative agreement.

When to use this skill

Trigger when the user is:

• triaging received PR comments on a GitHub pull request ("evaluate the review", "address the comments on PR #42", "what do the bots say on my PR")
• consolidating feedback from multiple reviewers on the same PR ("Copilot and CodeRabbit disagree", "merge what the three reviewers said", "cluster the bot comments")
• auditing earlier review feedback in this conversation ("go back and check the reviewer's notes", "self-eval the review comments from earlier")
• converting a markdown review/audit doc into an action plan (review.md, audit.md, feedback.md, *-review-notes.md)
• handling ambiguous "check the review" prompts with no source pointer — scan prior messages, then PR comments on the current branch, then markdown candidates
• deciding whether to implement, push back, or defer a specific suggestion against the actual code
• replying in PR threads with technical reasoning rather than gratitude

Do NOT use this skill when:

• performing the review yourself (reviewer-side, producing findings) → use do-review