critic-defender-judge

Installation
SKILL.md

Critic-Defender-Judge Strategy

Classic adversarial triangle: one agent attacks, one defends, one judges.

Method

  1. debate-architect designs attack vectors based on artifact type
  2. debate-critic generates structured attacks using Toulmin model
  3. debate-defender responds with counter-evidence and rebuttals
  4. debate-judge evaluates exchange quality and produces round verdict
  5. Repeat with escalating pressure (dialectical-escalation tactic)

Budget Table

Installs
1
GitHub Stars
505
First Seen
Aug 15, 2026