pc-panel-review
pc-panel-review — model the whole PC, not one reviewer
Which review skill?
paper-adversarial-review= one hostile reviewer, fast defect hunt.pc-panel-review(you are here) = the whole PC (N independent lenses incl. an artifact-runner) + a chair meta-review — the real pre-submission GATE, run LAST. This skill also has a Venue-fit mode (below): ONE reviewer scoring a named venue's CFP rubric to predict its accept/reject — the quick single-lens spot-check (formerly the standalonevenue-review-simskill). Reach for Venue-fit mode orpaper-adversarial-reviewfor a fast spot-check; run the full panel (this) for the decision.
The Venue-fit mode gives ONE reviewer's fit score; paper-adversarial-review gives ONE defect hunt.
A real decision is made by 2–4 reviewers with different priorities + a meta-review that weighs
consensus over any single voice. This skill runs that. The payoff over a single review: a must-fix
is what ≥2 independent reviewers flag — that filters real blockers from one reviewer's hobbyhorse —
and at least one reviewer executes the artifact, which surfaces paper↔artifact mismatches no
prose-only read can.